Skinny Versus Curvy Battle Time! Victoria Beckham or Beyonce?
May 6, 2008 in Beyonce, Skinny Versus Curvy, Victoria Beckham by Versus
Couldn’t come up with a more contrasting pair, don’t you agree? While Victoria Beckham has been the standard for “the ultimate skinny figure” and sometimes even for “scary skinny”, Beyonce is comfortably settled at the opposite pole, where she proudly represents the curvy figures. What do these ladies have in common? Well, they both attended the Metropolitan Museum of Art’s Costume Institute Gala last night, where they wore these light-colored dresses (no, Beyonce didn’t get bored of the mermaid dresses, apparently).
So, which one looks better? Who rocks her dress more? Who is more appealing, more stylish and overall more fab? Skinny versus curvy battle time! Choose your side: pin thin Victoria Beckham or voluptuous Beyonce?
Versus’s expert verdict: Let’s see: Sexier? Beyonce wins by some (many) hip inches. More stylish? Victoria, who looks like a high fashion magazine cover.
P.S. Yes, that IS David Beckham’s ear I cropped right there.
Sorry, but I choose victoria, so skinny wins in my book! she is one of my faves, beyonce really needs to lose a few and she’ll look better. like maybe 20 lbs.
j’aime victoria mais je prefer beyoncé on arrive à perçevoir l’art de la robe …quelques kilo de trop mais sa lui va à merveille.par contre moi en tant que femme et surtout personnelment malgrès qu’elle soit jolie la robe de victoria …elle m’attire pas vu le corp de vicy…
Beyonce looks so much better!! Victoria looks sickly like she has something. Victoria also goes straight down no curve or shape to her body what so ever. Beyonce has a great body and if she lost 20pds she look sick and starved just like Victoria.
[...] recently saw Beyonce looking like this. Now we can’t be sure how she looks now, cause the outfit is not giving us anything, no clue, [...]
VIctoria easily win this one, but it is unfair because she has an absolutly perfect body. She makes anyone look bad. She has the most attractive figure of any women on this site. Love her shape!
…She is emanciated looking…
What shape?
[...] Beyonce is shedding some pounds. I guess I was right and it is now safe to say so. Take a look at Beyonce almost two months ago and tell me if you [...]
I think saying Beyonce needs to lose 20 lbs is craaaaazy. Victoria aka Posh is too thin. Being too skinny can be just as unhealthy as being obese, if not worse. Ask your physician, I promise you this. I don’t support being too skinny nor over weight. Being in your healthy BMI is the way to go. Exercise, eat healthy, but don’t kill yourself to look like victoria. Everyones body is different…and I just think it is sad that the image we are portraying to little girls and boys out there is that this is what beauty “is.” It’s delusional and sad. Promote healthiness, not “skinny or fat.”
Beyonce is way sexier. I like what Jen says: Healthy is what to promote.
I PROUDLY choose Beyonce. Victoria is sending the wrong message that in order for you to be beautiful, you have to be stick thin. Don’t get me wrong, thin is okay if it is NATURAL. However not everyone’s body is made to be thin, and that’s okay. people who think that B should lose weight and she is too fat are the reason why girls and woman throw up after they eat, and starve themselves to acehive that “perfect” look. Besides, men prefer curvier women anyways. Beyonce is no where near fat as a matter of fact, she represents what women really should look like. Full Bust, full hips like a real woman. Like I said, skinny is natural as long as it’s natural. Didn’t Victoria had an eating disorder at one point? Besides, those who say that B needs to lose 20 pounds is crazy. I’m sorry, but I’m not going to put my finger down my throat to be a size 2.
They say “thin is in” but I say “fat is where it’s at!”
hear hear jessica!:)
beyonce looks fantastic and has amazing talent, victoria looks too thin and has absolutely zilch talent. in fact, i find it crazy that she is seen as anything more than just a footballers wife (admittedly a very famous footballer, but still).
ok whoever says that beyonce needs to lose weight or that victoria has a perfect body is crazy!
I think beyonce looks great, not to mention that she looks happy and healthy. victoria just looks gross… shes way too skinny
Victoria looks exactly like Cruella De ville here. I would usually say victoria, because I like her body better, but in this case Beyonce wins.
Both have bad hairstyles. Victoria is too thin and Beyonce too hefty.
Victoria’s face is scaring me.
Victoria wins, her face looks sorta scary here lol, but i lovee her body!
Victoria is absolutely the skinniest celeb I’ve ever seen in recent times.
If she is that small boned to boot, she could be very attractive. Obviously,
Beyonce is just a much larger woman in all areas, especially breasts and
booty, as well as quite noticeably in the thighs. Being much bigger boned
than Victoria doesn’t make her less attractive. Victoria wins the feminine
part as Beyonce is much stronger physically and many men like a Victoria,
but Beyonce can throw a curve that most batters could quiver over,
especially in that pick where she raises her skirt and reveals that tasty
looking booty. Very tough pick, but I wouldn’t advise Victoria to get any
thinner, nor would I advise Beyonce to get any heftier. Celeb wrestling
match would go to Beyonce very easily.
These 2 are such contrasting beauties. Posh is so tiny, slender, puny, the ultimate in ultra feminine, blow-away fragility. What is even more remarkable is that she is still still so delicately petite even after 2 children and 35 years. Beyonce, despite being much younger than Posh is taller and stronger, a much more powerful, athletic and more “womanly” beauty. How do you chose between 2 such different women, both so beautiful in such different ways. If pushed to make a decision I think I would go for Posh for her exciting combination of girlish delicacy and mature womanhood.