Skinny Versus Curvy Battle Time! Victoria Beckham Versus Kate Winslet!
November 4, 2008 in Kate Winslet, Skinny Versus Curvy, Victoria Beckham by Versus
As promised, here’s our trademark battle Skinny VS Curvy, featuring curvaceous Kate Winslet, who recently got furious because people believed that her Vanity Fair pictures were photoshopped. Now Kate has got a desirable figure, that’s true, but I can see why some might think that some pounds were, indeed, shedded artificially – Click here to judge for yourself!
As for Victoria, as-skinny-as-ever is the right phrase to describe her look – I wonder if she’ll ever get bored of the ultra thin look and embrace a curvier figure. Most likely, NOT.
On the left: one stick thin, skinnier-than-a-model figure and on the right: one figure that was always famous for its curves:
Skinny Versus Curvy Battle Time! Victoria Beckham Versus Kate Winslet! Choose your favorite!
How can you even ask that? Hehe. Of Course Kate Winslet, who is one of the most gorgeous women in Hollywood.
Posh is just person you only can laugh at.
I honestly prefer Victoria – I know that she’s too skinny, but I’m just thinking that I wouldn’t feel so comfortable in Kate’s body (not that there’s anything wrong with it), I would like to be a little slimmer.
And since I love fashion so much, I like Victoria better, because her skinny figure makes all the clothes look good. However, I wouldn’t want to be THAT skinny, but still I prefer Vic over Kate.
@ Anya,
I’m asking because I know that both girls have lots of fans. And since they look dramatically different, people love to share their thoughts and support their favorite!
I have to agree with Tina on this one. Although I do admit that Victoria is a bit too thin I still prefer her body over Kate’s.
kate is usually gorgeous this picture doesn’t do her justice!
Anya, I agree with you. In my book, Kate is the winner, no doubt about it.
same.
kate looks so much better
she looks like an actual woman, someone who would go to the beach and laugh with her friends and hang out in jeans and a tshirt and look sexy
posh is just this strange alien looking creature we all gawk at for entertainment. shes not real, downtoearth, or beautiful like kate
I totally agree with Stef! Kate is soooo gorgeous! Posh weighs less than her kids, and a third of what her husband weighs, I bet.
ok posh isn’t skinnier than a model figure. sorry. i still adore kate.
altho i love kate and think she has a good figure… but i wouldn’t feel comfortable in it (just like tina)
so i guess beckham.
and also i get 2 eat whatever i want!
I prefer Kate, clothes look better on a body like hers.
Victoria!! I love her skinny, little body. I like Kate too… I would pick her if she was compared to someone other than Posh.
Versus: As you can see, I was only “kidding” about the ” how can you ask that question” question.
Shannon: Yes Posh is skinner that a lot of the models, even though Gisele, Miranda, Heidi is taller than her, they all look nothing like Victoria Beckham. Because Posh isn’t skinny, she is scarily skinny.
Kate Winslet!
I have to admit, I much prefer Posh. What can I say, skinny IS my ideal. I know she’s nearly an unhealthy weight, she’s so tiny, but I’m still jealous! I think the outfit is a bit overkill, but she’s still amazing. I’d really rather look like a prepubescent boy than a curvy average-sized woman, sick as that may be…
LOL….im with you E, call me sick all you want…ha ha
wow….. some of your are F***ED up
hands down KATE WINSLET!!!
I of course would pick Kate Winslet. She has cuves in the right places and there is nothing wrong with that. Anon, I agree with you on your comment. I think Kate is so pretty!!!!
I think it’s crazy for women to want to look like a boy, but I guess. All the guys I know like women with a butt and sexy full theighs. I didn’t say fat, I said full. I say Kate looks better. I’m not going to pick a super skinny nasty looking Victoria Beckham. She use to be sexy when she was in spice girls. What happended?!?
LOL Corbin, I agree with you. I like curvy women
Same with me.
Kate Winslet is so hot!!!! I think curvy women are sexy. I’m a pretty thin guy and I wouldn’t want a girl who is as bony as me. I prefer women size 3 and up.
Kate looks healthier and better than posh spice. Skinny is cute sometimes, but in this case, Kate wins this round
I’d rather be curvy rather than a toothpic.
kaaaaaaaaaaaaaaate
Kate looks a trillion times better. Victoria aka posh spice needs to gain tons of weight. She looks like a bird to me LOL. I agree with you Corbin. She was so much preetier when she was posh spice, she had a fuller figure. And with a figure like Kate’s she can fill out a dress with her curves and look fantastic!!!!
Kate is soooooooooooo Gorgeous.
Posh is just….Melon on a 2×4.
I love Kate Winslet. I was actually just watching “The Holiday” the other day.
Love her (Hourglass?) figure.
Victoria Beckham.. meh.. I’ve gotten used to her tiny figure. Most of us British just don’t care anymore. She can do what she wants with her health.
Kate Winslet is obviously the winner for me.
@ Linda,
Yes, Kate is definitely an hourglass, one of the most representative hourglasses out there. We’ll try to find a (red carpet) picture that shows off her 8 figure!
well, i would say victoria. although those pictures arent flattering.
[...] is very verbal about her “NOto Photoshop!” mission, I can’t help noticing that Kate is not that slim in real life (and no, I’m not saying she should [...]
hi
xgx645lklgie8b6e
good luck
kate for sure! and i tottaly agree with you to corbin.
kate is sexy as hell! victoria can do what she wants, but her skinny ‘figure’ does nothing for me. im all for difference body shapes, but its strange to want to look like a boy
My God, what a silly question!
Kate wins, hands down! Anyone who thinks that Voctoria looks good, or that they themsevles would like to have a figure like Victoria’s, is out of their minds!
I am a size 7 and have large breasts like Kate and honestly, men love my figure. My husband thinks it’s so hot to be with a woman who has boobs, hips and a butt. He is not into freakishly skinny women. So ladies, not all men like size 2′s. Most women are not naturally built that way, they are most likely starving themselves, which is quite sad.
Kate, all the way, you go girl!
not all men like size 7′s either…
victoria looks way better
Kate, if you want a real woman.
Victoria if you want the equivalent of a 12 yr old girl haha, how does David Beckham find that attractive?! Shes a sour-faced stick.
Sorry, I agree with all of the Posh-lovers, I would rather be thin and not have all of that meat-I cant stand the way “curves” feel on my body, Id rather feel bone…or I feel fat. Sorry, if you think I’m “sick”, cause it is not only what a guy thinks….I have to like the way I look in my clothes or I won’t feel confident and sexy anyway….Posh, hands-down!! (kate is gorgeous and the curves look good on HER, I’m not saying that I think everyone who has curves is fat, I just personally don’t like it on ME).
That does not sound like a healthy attitude, IMO.
Perhaps it is not, but I know no other way. I cannot explain it other than i can’t stand the feeling of flesh….it makes me ill. Even if people tell me I look better with weight, i simply cannot bear it. I feel disgusted with myself. Like I said, It is not that I look at other people and think THEy look fat, in fact, I think they are beautiful!! It just doesn’t work on me. And I’d rather no man find me attractive if that was the price tag. Because I know I would be unhappy. Models are thin because that is what fashion looks good on. I will admit though that if I do not see bone I cease in finding it attractive. Maybe it is unhealthy but at least it won’t drive me crazy feeling like a fat, disgusting pig who can grab hunks of flesh on my hips and thighs….even now I want to lose more… I wish I was THAT tiny….(sigh). If a pair of sz 4 jeans wouldn;t fit-I won’t eat.period.
Kate is just gorgeous. I’m so happy she finally got an Oscar.
Ok, so this is going to sound bitchy BUT I bet the girls that are picking KATE look more like KATE and the ones picking VIC are tinier. I say this because I am a size 1/2 and of course I’d pick Victoria….why would I want to be bigger (Cause I am guessing Kate is like a size 6) BUT if I were a size 10 I’d say Kate because a size 1/2 would seem unattainable. AND USUALLY girls that are curvy or may be chubby are gonna say they like curvy chicks, it is more realistic of a goal for them than trying to look stick thin.
Kate. Without a second thought.
I don’t think Victoria is pretty at all. She NEVER leavs her home without make up and even with make up on and totally fixed a natural kate winslet looks 10000000 times better. Kate has the eyes, the cheeks, the lips, eyebrows, body and MIND. While Victoria, only has the money and power.
OFCOURSE KATE TAKES THIS ONE!