Which Pair of Legs Do You Prefer? Guess Them if You Can!
June 1, 2009 in Body Comparisons, Skinny Versus Curvy, Take a Guess! by Versus

Skinny legs or shapelier legs?
Which size and shape of legs do you prefer? The very thin ones on the left or the meatier ones on the right?
Pick your favorite pair, then check after the jump and see who owns them!

Sienna Miller and Rumer Willis!
So which pair of legs do you like better?









OMG!!!!! How old is Sienna Miller????
I would have never guessed these were her legs….. It looks more they belong to somebody in her late 40s, early 50s……. ooooopssss!!!!!!
She’s 27!
I was thinking the exact same thing. I can’t believe she is only 27! Even her face looks older than 27 but not as old as her legs.
neither one of them .looks like rumer has put on a few pounds.
wt the hell, Sienna Miller legs… suck
I’m not keen on either legs, but I will say Sienna because she is gorgeous.
I don’t like any of those legs, but I’ll pick Sienna just because she’s so damn gorgeous and I really really like her natural style, even if she’s so skinny.
What is going on with Sienna’s tan on legs it’s so un even uuggh I hate it, looks like giraffe:(
wow.
ummm rumer. ??
although she does look a little pudgy.
i prefer her legs. so much healthier.
sienna looks sick. maybe she should lay of the drugs and whoring around. might actually do her body some good.
and to think a few years ago she was the ‘it’ girl. she was so much hotter in her Alfie days.
I thought Sienna’s legs were Paris Hilton’s! (That’s not a good thing!)
me too
WOW! I didn’t like either pair of legs but seeing who they belong to I was really surprised.
I’d still have to say Sienna just because they’re thinner but the bumpiness is kinda gross.
I’d certainly go with the shapelier legs but they are the skinnier legs. Bigger legs generally has less shape than skinnier legs..
I’d give this to Sienna..
LOL, no, bigger legs tend to have more shape than skinnier legs.
I don’t care for either pair but Sienna usually has nice legs. Maybe it’s just the lighting?
Wow Sienna has lost a lot of weight if you compare her to the topless photos of her last summer with Balthasar Getty where she was slim and healthy. I wonder what height and weight she is now?
I knew it was Sienna
I definitely prefer her legs.
rumer is SUCH an ungly kid, I don’t know why she didn’t inherit any of her parents’ beauty
Definitely Sienna’s legs. They aren’t the best, but I love thin legs as opposed to thicker ones.
i would’ve guessed someone like Teri Hatcher, though i knew it wasn’t her, but something of the likes.. And when someone asked how old Sienna is, i actually misremembered her being in her mid 30′s or 40′s, ouups indeed. Rumers legs have potential to look fab w/ definition, colour and a bit less meat on them, maybe. Whereas Sienna just looks veiny.. Maybe a couple of pounds would help but i think she just doesn’t age well ’cause she might be too strict with herself.
I think Rumer’s legs would look a lot better in different shoes. The cut on those ones aren’t very flattering so I vote Rumer. Sienna’s legs look strange.
sienna’s legs look a bit sickly….
Sienna’s look far better.
Too skinny vs too thick. Both would look better with some definition and toning up, both need muscle, both need to do something about the messy look. Verdict: neither. Not atractive to me.
goodness when did rumer get fat?
Umm, she’s not fat.
She’s not fat, right. But she is soft. And she is next to marisa. Who wouldn’t look fat next to that?
OF COURSE Sienna’s legs. I wish my legs were like those. Sienna has a wonderful body.
why are there so many scars on siennas legs? that looka creepy, but she has a beautiful face…
I have a feeling people aren’t too keen on the curvier legs because they belong to rumer and the same goes for Siennas legs actually. My honest first impression was gross to the legs on the left and that the legs on the right were a great pair of pins! I’m also schocked people find rumer plump which if you look at the average woman then she is most definitly NOT plump.
Me too!
I can seen why people prefer Sienna’s legs but i’m surprised that they see Rumer as fat. I don’t think these pics do either of them justice but i think Rumer’s legs look fine, though i agree with the comment on her shoes, they don’t do her legs much justice.
I don’t see how you can have healthy legs. To me healthy legs are legs that can run, skip and jump like they should! It’s the body that is either healthy or unhealthy. Someone may have a healthy weight but depending on their body type e.g. top heavy, bottom heavy, they will look bigger in certain areas in comparison to the rest of their bodies but that doesn’t mean one area of the body is healthier than the other!
neither look very toned? i’m not sure if it’s just the images but sienna looks too skinny, like sick, ruma’s legs are a great shape but they look really bland and not very toned (or moisturised)! i’m not too sure on this one
rumer’s not “fat” but she’s definitely not thin…. i love sienna and her legs- i dont think they’re too skinny she’s always had legs like that i wish mine were that skinny and toned!
I don’t car how old they look I’ll always want the skinnier…becaues mine are thick and athletic, damn running
OfCourse Rumer’s !
Sienna’s Legs Look like an old woman’s leg …
Actually neither. Before i saw the pics, then i thought rumer’s legs, if had to choose, bc the other pair looks old and too thin, but when i saw the whole picture, i would probably pick sienna bc she is gorgeous, though still not crazy about the knee area.
Sorry, your knee just should not be the thickest part of your leg.