More of Curvy Michelle and Skinny Jessica
February 17, 2009 in Body Comparisons, Body Type and Clothes, Jessica Stroup, Michelle Trachtenberg by Versus

In case you didn’t get enough in our latest Skinny VS Curvy battle, here’s a bonus featuring Michelle and Jessica!
These girls are both obviously pretty in their own (skinny or curvy) way and I really just have 1 comment: those shoes were NOT made for Michelle’s legs.
Also pictures, actress Adrianne Palicki (from Friday Night Lights).
Check out 2 more after the jump!











Jessica looks sad
I hope she didn’t get bad news recently.
Jessica is very skinny but she is gorgeous!!!!!
The blonde girl looks the best, she is so pretty!
Sorry but Michelle’s legs are nasty. Bleached tree trunks.
She is sickly pale and sorry to say not a very nice shape at ALL
They are all three pretty girls, for sure. But Michelle does have some chubby legs, sorry, but it is true. And you are right, those shoes are not doing her any favors.
Adrianne Palicki ? she looks like the joker from batman with that smile and all that s lipstick on.
Jessica is not skinny,she is slim. major difference. when she had a eating disorder way back she was skinny. now she is slim which is good.
*@ missy: jessica has eating disorder ,AGAIN? No way! (O)__(0) when was this?! When did i miss thsi news?
if so I take me words of endearment back…
I agree with runner girl with michelle,and why does she ALWAYS pick the wrong shoes her her bodytpe? she is very pretty though,and has nice upper body.
Michelle looks good, she’s very pretty i love her
michelle has a body that most men would want their gf’s to look likeee.
she looks like a goddess in the second picc.
You are so right about Michelle’s shoes….
Michelle is so pretty, but dear lord she could use some gym time… I think getting a little less “soft” would take her into a league of her own. But then again, woman ARE supposed to be soft….
Jessica Stroup is pretty, but she looks better with a little more meat on her bones. I thought she got that skinny for attention, but it seems like she really may be sick…. poor girl:(
what? women are SUPPOSED to be soft? what rule book did you read this is? I am allowed to be strong, toned, and firm and still feminine.
they both look good but still I think Jessica as a hotter look! Michelle looks too pale and too soft for my taste
michelle is fat.
No she’s not.
No, she’s curvy.
Jessica looks like a young Courtney Cox, no?
She was always teetering on the verge of scary skinny, too, but for now its in check.
Michelle could afford to go to the gym more, but is still gorgeous. Oh and she has the best posture out of all 3. Working with what she has, but what’s with the ankles. Maybe she should do a sequel to Ice Princess to get back in shape. Gorgeous though.
Jessica looks like her eyes are scared and are looking for help. Not healthy looking, especially in the 2nd picture. However, she’s till very sexy.
Except for that clownish makeup and smile, the third girl looks very good. I’d like to see more pictures of her because it looks like she’s skinny, but not too skinny.
Wow, Michelle’s complexion and facial features make her GORGEOUS, but the other ladies are quite pretty, too! This is a win for Michelle in my part.
Seriously asking this – has Michelle gained a little bit of weight since Ice Princess?
Why on earth does Michelle always wear shoes that don’t suit her legs? The number one rule for chunkier legs (and god knows i abide by it all the time) is DO NOT wear ankle straps, they do not flatter. She does look gorgeous though, she can look AMAZING when she wears the right shoes but she still looks fab. Shame Jessica is so skinny, she’d be gorgeous otherwise!
who is the other girl with wavy blondy hair>?
michelle can’t help her genes of heavy legs, she has a nice upper body though
Jessica is reallly skinny but she looks really good here
Except for her legs (which I find no fault in, personally), Michelle looks like perfection. Gorgeous complexion, face.
anyone else noticed that michelles shoes are not just unflattering, but also way to big, what is up with that, she should have enough money to buy shoes the right size..
I noticed that too, I think she may have narrow feet or something along those lines so she wears ankle strap shoes so her feet stop sliding forwards, if she didn’t everytime she lifts her feet the shoes would come off I reckon. I have narrow and shallow feet and stilettos rarely stay on properly. So I HAVE to get shoes with straps (although I stick with straps on my feet rather than ankles as I don’t have long, thin legs) or I have to wear shoes that are a size too small- very painful by the end of the night.
On second look, I think she has narrow heels.
they both looks great.. michelle is so pretty!
and i love the tanned body of jessica
wow i wonder what michelle’s legs look like in person because they look very big in the pics. but then again she’s sitting next to true size 0 stick figures so who knows?
Sitting next to a former anorexic is going to make most people look “curvy”,
its no wonder girls get eating disorders however with the likes of everyone passing judgement on their body shape.
These are young women – their bodies are going through all manner of growth processes and all you lot can moan about is whether someone is fat or not??
As someone else rightly pointed out, there are genetics involved!
And as a further point from a photographers view – its a particularly unflattering angle in the first picture.
Michelle is so cute but I really don’t find her legs attractive. The rest of her seems fine to me though. Someone really ought to urge her not to wear shoes with straps across the ankles.
Michelle could wrap those “thick, pale tree trunks” around me anytime! What a well developed woman!
Michelle could wrap those “thick, pale, tree trunks” around me anytime! What a well developed woman!
Jess and the blond girl look great. Michelle has by far the ugliest legs I’ve ever seen!!
I have very similar legs to Michelle…..and I above all know not to wear ankle straps or low heels with my legs…she should know to. but I am very pleased to at least know Im not the only only one with meaty legs without being overweight.
seriously Michelle’s legs aren’t fat at all. the first pic is just an unflattering angle, which you can tell from the other pics. her legs just aren’t as skinny as the girl with the silver shoes, which makes them look bigger by comparison. all of them have very slim legs.