Which Lindsay Do You Prefer? Curvy Lindsay VS Skinny Lindsay!
February 23, 2009 in Body Type and Clothes, Lindsay Lohan, Skinny Versus Curvy, Then and Now by Versus
Curvy Lindsay is from a few years back. Plus points: she looks healthy and she’s a redhead. Minus points: the unnatural tan.
Skinny Lindsay is from last night. Plus points: the dress, which is white and pleated and it gives her a “curvier” shape. Plus, the dress covers Lindsay’s skinniest parts: her shoulders and chest, so she doesn’t look as terribly skinny. Minus points: she’s obviously (and unnaturally) underweight.
Check out how much her face has changed because of the weight loss – where is she prettier?
Which Lindsay Do You Prefer? Curvy Lindsay VS Skinny Lindsay!
Pick your favorite!
More pictures of the skinny Lindsay after the jump!
Well, I have to say skinny in these pictures. However, in other pictures of her curvy days she looks better. The unnatural tan, giant hair, ugly fashion choice make her look horrible. She ooks more sophisticated in the skinny pictures, but should still gain some weight.
Yeah first (lol such a troll)
I prefer curvier Lindsay, her face looks cute. However, the clothes are horrible. Skinnier Lindsay has a killer dress, but since I know from other photos how skinny she is, I can’t choose her.
Oh, and how come her boobs look bigger in the skinny picture? Hm, weird… And no, I don’t think it’s the clothes.
I’m not sure if she’s had a boob job or not, and I’m not going to speculate that she has because it feels a bit rude for me to do that
But I will point out that the curvier picture was taken a few years ago, and Lindsay is only 22, so she was still a teen when that pic was taken. Some women’s boobs continue to grow into their twenties, so there’s one theory 
Personally, bad styling aside, Lindsay looks a lot better in the curvy picture. And IMO, it looks like it is way more than a few years that separates those pictures, looks more like 10+(not doubting your word on the time frame, Versus, just saying that going by looks, I would have never guessed the right time frame).
Neither. Somewhere in the middle would be perfect. But I adsolutely LOVE the white dress from yesterday! I want one!
I agree with you completely.
It’s so true.
you took the words right out of my mouth…
she has been curvier than on the left picture. i think she looks healthier on the left pic, but the tan is awful.
Ehhhhhh, I hate to say it, but skinny wins for me. She’s just a tiny bit too chubby in her younger pics for my taste. She’s a tad too thin now, but I like the look more.
I prefer the curvy Lindsay. She looks happier (IMO) and I love her Red Hair. I miss the Old Lindsey.
Oops I meant Lindsay not Lindsey.
Agree with you! She used to be so sweet and feminine! A cute red-haired curvy girl… She seems so different in these pictures.. Like another person…
Neither. She is so overrated.
I’d have to say the skinny one. The skinny look works for her. Maybe gain a little weight, but she looks a whole lot better skinny.
She looks so much better curvier, her eyes look brighter and she just looks more healthy even with tangerine tan. Her skin looks tired and blotchy in the skinny picks and her proportions are so out of balance its a wonder she doesnt fall over.
She looks horrible skinny. It’s so unnatural on her,
well i prefer curvy out of these- but she just needs to find the balance in between them. When she was curvy as we can see she looks really healthy, glowing and happy (not sure if the glowing is part of that awful, cheap looking fake tan). I’m happy that she’s accepting her skin colour but i think it’s time for her to hang up the blonde image and go back to her original red, because that was gorgeous. She looks really ill as well, like she’s on something. In the first pciture she just looks really natrual and youthful. It’s a real shame how fame and money affect some people, that’s why i think young girls are just too young to be given so much power and wealth and fame, they just dont know what to do with themselves.
Lindsay circa 2003/2004 was the happiest.
I dont like the legs of the curvy Lindsay. The face at least looks better on curvy version. The legs on the skinny version are super.
Yeah, don’t you just love those emaciated anorexic sick skinny legs of hers?
i miss “mean girls” lindsay.
Me too!! Whenever i used to watch that movie i always thought she looked amazing and wished i looked like her!
mehhh.. not LOVING either.. shes a little too chunk in the first pic.. and concensus. ugly, terrible spray on tan.. damn girl! you got money.. at least get a good tan?!?! Looks a little emaciated in the second pic.. though slightly hotter than the chunk. I AGREE WITH SANDRA. that girl was BANGIN in Mean Girls.. Lindsey, WHAT HAPPENED?
I’m really sorry but I’m going to have to go with skinny Lindsay. I really can’t stand how portly she looks on the original picture.
Ha ha. You people make me sick.
skinny lindsay has nice legs but the rest of her is too skinny. I agree somewhere in between theses two pics would be and ideal weight
The skinny pic is much better, her face was too round or chubby before and her legs didn’t look that great.
SKINNY! <3
Personally…the curvy version.
skinny is way better… she looked very chubby in the first pic.. now you can see her facial features better, and you can actually see her waist.
Ew
I feel that there is too much exaggeration with her shape in the left pic (for those who are calling her chubby). She looks healthy and happy. She just has curves. Doesn’t mean she’s chunky.
curves means to have waist definition…. she doesn’t have that in the first picture….. You can see it more in the second pic… maybe its her outfit.. but I just don’t like the way she looks in the first pic… it’s all a matter of opinion.
I like the first pic. I still belive that she’s curvy. If not, then she’s definatly not chunky. I take the word chunky as overweight. And in the first pic she isn’t. I just think Lindsay Lohan should get help. I would love to say she looks great skinny, but seeing how she got that way is kind of scary.
Neither. I really don’t find her the least bit decent looking curvy or skinny. Her appearance honestly makes me want to go take a bath.
Curvy Lindsay! Her eyes look brighter, which is a sign of good health (ask any European doctor on that one!) Also, her natural beauty shines through with her glowing skin, shiny red hair, and beautiful icy blue eyes. Skinny Lindsay looks like grandma: dull leathery skin, sparse hair, sunken cheeks, and saggy boobs.
SKINNY
you can tell she is eating better (fish, vegetables ect) and she just looks so much more attractive and probably sleeps better as well!
better? or nothing..?
Watch the interview she did with E! that night, and then tell me she is thin from eating fish and steamed veggies.
wierd!! I just tried to order that dress a few days ago online but it got sold out!!! i was like, awwwwwwww!! theyre going to order more so i shall try again! If i do buy it, i will starve for like 3 months!
)
(ladies,it’s alexander wang in case your interested
oh to the above comment, I say starve because of the money that usually goes to food and what not will be going to the dress! I’m not promoting starvation to fit into a little dress! just thought you should know…
“chubby” “chunky” “the chunk” “portly”, people fawning over the too skinniness and putting down the healthier weight. Damn, no wonder this poor girl feels like she has to be half starved.
skinny lindsey… altho gaining 5 lbs (currently) won’t be awful.
hmm…skinny?????
Curvy Lindsay or like someone else says her mean girls days she looked great back then also she needs to go back to being a red head the blonde is so overated and boring the red brought more hcaracter IMO and made her look lkie she had an once of life in her now she looks blah
well for one thing I think that this comparison is sooo not far. This is like the least atractive picture of her..so course skinny lindsay looks better. but i think that lindsay does need to gain weight…
I know that curvy Lindsay’s outfit is not great, you can judge solely based on her shape and not on her whole look (ignore clothes & tan).
I chose this pic because she was showing off arms and legs (like skinny Lindsay) and they were shot from the same angle.
I can not believe that people are calling curvy Lindsay “chubby.” I’m not a fan of calling people out, but you people are unbelievable.
Well said. I agree wholeheartedly. Curvy does NOT equal chubby.
skinny look nicer just here, but she is underweight..I m stil wondering, struggeling to be at 32 y old a size 6 for 172 cm high, how she manage to surive ..I work as a lawyer and if I cut off all my food intake at least during the day I can not work !!!
I know celeb/stars have all day to go to the gym- chef that cooks for them healty stuff but this is a bit too far..she is 10 years younger too so methabolism must be quicker..still it is amazing how much she lost these last month!
you’re a lawyer???? thats amazing. didnt think a lawyer could be quite so inarticulate.
yes I am a lawyer at the European Commission – Blegium- Europe if you know where it is, and English is only my forth language, that is why probably your peanuts size brain find my statement inarticulate..that was indeed a more articulate reflection vis a vis all this skinny/chubby comments..the reason under this in my opinion is the real key- how and why she got so skinny.
hehe, despite you are right i wouldnt want to provoke you in court..
I hope you don’t speak like this in court? Are you sure the judge understands you?
I doubt she would be speaking English in the courts she would be in.
To the “smart” Rellie …and last post I promise webmaster:
Despite the fact that I m writing thisquickly as I should not waist too much time even if I adore celeb gossip, so I do not pay attention to typo mistakes.. –
writing/speaking are not the same thing, and yes I speak ranch Italian Spanish AND English in the European court, actually never had a complaint about my English as I m almost mother tongue speaker(studied in Uk too.. )
As I would say in Court stop this post as they are not relevant to the case – Lindsay skinny or not- and I doubt you are qualified to make such comment or you even know what is going on in courts..
I think that in the left picture she has a great figure but that dress and tan don’t do anything for her. As for now, she looks pasty and unwell.
I don’t think she’s chunky in the left pic at all! I feel she is just right. I prefer the curvy Lindsey becuase she’s a lot healhier. Ever since I saw that other pic of her in the pink strapless dress, I can’t say that she’s great skinnier. Plus her red hair seems so natural and georgous. Now I can tell she’s not happy behind that smile.
curvy lindsay is not chubby. i see and think the in the left picture she looks gorgeous, has a nice legs. the skinny lindsay is too thin for my taste.
the question is, rather, which do you prefer: Lindsay pre-drugs, or Coked-out Lindsay?
Curvy Lindsay for sure!
Although i know all the anorexic wannabes will be hailing the skinny skeletal version of Lindsay. It really is pathetic. No wonder this poor girl felt she needed to lose the weight if people are saying shes “thick” or “chubby” in her curvy picture when she is just happy and very healthy there. The whole size 0 thing makes me sick – anorexia is not a game. You shouldn’t play with your health like that. For God’s sake, some people don’t have limbs, they would give anything to have a normal healthy body and yet here are people complaining because they’re not stick thin?! This is a very sensitive and important issue – thousands of girls are dying from eating disorders, dying to achieve this, and by Lindsay (along with other celebs) conforming to this, it is only encouragement. So well done Lindsay, for going from a happy healthy and perfectly attractive girl to an anorexic sick skeleton. And thanks also for being “thinspiration” to my friend who is dying of an eating disorder. We need a lot more of the celebs who refuse to conform like Lily Allen for example who is curvacious and a great example.
Thank goodness. Size 0 does not mean your world is going to come together. If that were so, we’d see Lindsey happy with Sam and acting appropriately. She’d be working on actual movies and maybe helping other people.
Celebs like Brittany Snow and Hillary Duff are great inspirations because they are beautiful but aren’t size 0; they also admit to having had eating disorders and being miserable. I’ve been a size 00, it’s not amazing if you’re not supposed to be that skinny.
I’m going to have to dispute the Lily Allen part..
But I agree with the rest of what you said. It’s truly amazing how glamorized anorexia is. Why aren’t we learning from this? Why aren’t we changing?
Weight wise, Curvy def. However generally, I prefer neither. Girl’s got no hope because she’s got no style. Why does she always look so filthy? She’s reminds me of Pigpen from Charlie Brown, with this massive cloud of dust following her around. Yuck. Plus she has NO talent. She only shot to fame because of how precocious she was as a child. She’s so ‘drama school’. She should have stopped at the Parent trap and made room for more amazing young actress’ to come up through the ranks and have a chance. Mean girls would have been just as good if not better with someone else playing her role, and as far as I can tell to date that is the only movie of hers I would happily sit through. Waste of space. I apologize for being so abrasive but it gets on my nerves when young people are given all the chance at success in the world and then blow it all on drugs and partying. Please just take your money, move aside and make way for people who actually want to WORK in the industry, like me, and stop making a mockery of it.
Can’t agree with everything you said there, but she does remind me of pig pen now that you mention it. That’s really weird. I’m not going to lie, I liked her in Life Size (why I am admitting that? Yes, it is a shitty movie but when you’re a kid and Tyra is like all that and a bag of potato chips to you, you enjoy it).
Whats up Girlz
I think she looks good anyway she is
I don’t see the need to nitpick
ZuD
skinny lindsay!!
Come on now… Do you really have to ask??
Of douse she looked better when she wasn’t underweight…she looked pretty
Now she looks like a hag
I PREFER SOMEWHERE IN THE MIDDLE
curvy but with a better outfit
Skinny Lindsay. I would usually say curvy but she looks better skinny in these pictures
Disturbing.
yeh!
she looks good…i would love to have her figure!!
She looks awful in the first photo. Bloated , orange ,and undefined…however the second photo is equally gastly…She looks svelte,sophiticated,and like she isabout to die at any moment. she needs an intervention..and quick. She is such a beautiful young women. I hope she does nto do her body any long term damage with this rail thin kick she seems to keep gravitating towards….I like tobe super fit but always check myslef when I start to go litle crazy witht he calorie restrictions and over the top excercizing. It jsut isn’t healthy. The body has to be taken care of!!
I take that back. She just has a bit of “baby fat” and a a not so great tan but she looks healthy and still in her right mind!!
shes fat in the first pic…and the second pic shes alright..she could gain a little more esp with the arms.
ITS CRAZY BUT I ENVY HER NEW SKINNY BODY
MAKES ME SICK. WISH I COULD SAY THE CURVIER ONE.
IM SURE GUYS WOULD SAY THE CURVIER ONE THOUGH. THANK GOD
lol
i know wat u mean….wen i saw her pics…about her recnet weight lost
it was sick for me to think it…but i thought WOW…amazing figure!
maybe becos i want her figure and im trying to lose weight, so when i saw the piks i was like…i want THAT BODY!!
she lloks really good though!
Skinny!! Looks hot
curvy linds in skinny dress!
very interesting that many people are picking the skinny lindsay… despite the well known fact that she does drug and had eating disorder to look like that… very interesting
i think lindsay looks better curvy in my opinion, but more like how she was in mean girls.