Skinny Vs Curvy Battle Time! Victoria Beckham Vs Kim Kardashian!
February 18, 2009 in Kim Kardashian, Skinny Versus Curvy, Victoria Beckham by Versus
Oh, this is definitely a classic. Why? Because we’re pairing 2 extremes: one super skinny girl with one super curvy girl. Oddly enough, this is their first battle together.
Totally pointless to point out the differences, right? I thought so. Let’s decide then!
Skinny Vs Curvy Battle Time! Victoria Beckham Vs Kim Kardashian!
Choose your side!
I love them , i love the fact tha Posh is classy and stylish every single time we see her.I like the dress, it is not the tipe of dress she usually wears ,so it’s a good change…i also like Kim’s body , she’s famous 4 nothing, but she is a beautiful girl,and i would very much like 2 look like her ,exept the very big butt…
Forever and always Kim. Not that’s ( imo) how a real woman should look. Posh is nothing but a stick with boyish hair.
And what about the women that aren’t curvy like Kim, but are healthy? Aren’t they real women?
I myself like the curvier/fuller body like Kim’s, but isn’t a little wrong to say that her body type is the only real body type that women should be/look like?
i absolutely agree with you. this whole “real woman” thing does my head in! what are slim women supposed to be then…robots?
wow another stupid comment. anya not all women can look like kim and not every woman can look like victoria either. victoria may be thin but she looks good to me and so does kim. women are women, obviously you don’t understand.
although victoria beckham consists on 900 calories a day (or less) and starves herself whereas it is quite obvious that Kim Kardashian does not.
i think anya deserves a bit of a break here. Slim women are fine, yes… victoria secret models who look like they really are naturally thin… Posh does not fit this description.
“real women” = fat women.
you punks dont say this about victoria secret models and they are thin too.
You seem bitter and angry towards women that aren’t thin. Why? Kim, Jlo, Brit, they are all fit and fine, not fat at all, why do you think they are?
Even David I’m sure is sick of sleeping with a bag of bones. Kim has a real and more realistic woman’s body. This site finally got it right, that’s what a curvy woman looks like.
Kim’s body isn’t realistic, it’s cosmetically altered, and not many women look like that. Also, she isn’t “white” and doesn’t represent a white body type,like Posh does. They aren’t comparable.
And to note, Posh is cosmetically altered too.
Neither, yuck. But if forced to choose Kim.
I think Posh is a little too skinny, but she has very distinct facial features and fashion. Hell, she can pull of a Peter Pan cut and look sexy. Kim is also very sexy. I’m leaning toward Posh only because she’s so distinct, but she could stand to gain a few pounds if she is restricting her calorie intake as many mags say.
wow im goining to go with kim….
Kim looks fantastic. She seems to be a little more fit than she has been in the past, and she can rock a dress.
If Vicky could gain 15 lbs, she could rock that dress a little better.
Prediction: the majority of people are going to pick Kim with comments like ‘real woman’ etc. etc. attached.
Victoria looks fantastic,love the dress,shoes and her hair! I always thought she was petite o_O she looks very tall and leggy in this photo though, and on that note great legs.
But for who looks better, Fashion wise it goes to posh, body-wise hands down to Kim,love her curves and shes beautiful!
VIVA KIM VIVA CURVY GIRLS ! and btw i am trying to make myself better cus i am curvy kim really does look GREAT
I don’t think Kim needs to wear a dress with hip rouching (sp?) to make her look even more hippy…I would choose Posh here because her dress is a lot better on her body type. Kim needs a lot of balance in her outfits because of her curvy shape and this one-shouldered business throws the balance off and is not flattering.
I must say Posh. She is always fabulous and classy. They both take fashion risks all the time but Posh’s are always interesting and she always rocks them, no matter how bizarre they are. The girl is fierce!
For all of you who pick Kim because she’s “real” – Real women aren’t just one type. They can be curvy [like kim] or lean and elegant like Posh. Different, but equally feminine and beautiful. In the end, it’s all about how attitude and confidence.
Well if you read what I wrote which was IMO, then Im allowed to say that for me personally, that is how a real woman looks.
i am a real woman and i am skinny, not quite posh skinny, but if i lost about 5 pounds i would be. you sayin im not a real woman?
lol if you looked like posh after losing “5 pounds” (I do believe those would be a very difficult 5 pounds to lose indeed, if you are being honest) I would be very, very concerned for you.
Both looking gorgeous and elegant. I really think Victoria suits being very thin, she has such sexy legs and since she’s stopped all those ridiculous stroppy, pouting poses she’s looking so beautiful facially. However I still prefer Kim, she has an outstandingly sexy, curvy figure and looks gorgeous here apart from that stupid frill on her shoulder- big titted girls should stay well clear of frills I reckon.
Kim. She looks great here… But I think the dress should be like some inch lower…
*inches
Did you mean Posh’s dress should be inches lower, because she is the one who’s skirt is almost at her crotch!
Kim all the way
victoria with 10/15 pounds more.
real women are skinny, curvy, fat, thin.
don’t say real is curvy just cause its difficult to get and stay thin (not talking about unhealty looks)
Well you should try and read what we write, because I made it clear that, that is what I think how a real woman is supposed to look like.
And it is not difficult to get thin and stay that way, a lot of people do and are healthy thin. You are just making excuses for yourself.
anya, ive about had it with your comments. for some people it is difficult to get thin. im not one of them, its natural for me to just be thin, but i have people in my family who struggle with their weight constantly. you have no right to speak to any of us the way you are. and im only commenting on all of your comments because you seem to think everyone is making comments directed towards you when they are just making general statements.
excuses for what?
why are women supposed to look curvy? i said women can come in many different sizes, and they are all still women. women are not supposed to be anything.
who stablished that?
kim ftw! she is beautiful , i can’t stand victoria .. kim’s dress is very pretty and compliments her perfectly
i like kim better..she’s hot
Victoria’s, what, 5’4? (which is like average height in my opinion, NOT short or not tall) And her legs look like they never end, which is pretty awesome. I like how Kim doesn’t dress trashy; she looks like something out of Sex and the City!
Actually posh is about 5ft8.
she is nowhere near 5ft 8.. sorry
i hate it when people think that the reason why i chose kim is because i feel she has a real womans body…. i know real women have different bodies and i know some are slender, curvy, over-weight, too thin and to them this is just natural. i personally have a thinner and more toned body than kim… i just think she looks better because she doesnt look like she spends all day trying to be a specific body type… victoria on the other hand looks like she exercises way too much just look at her upper body…she has great legs i wont lie…but the point is dont assume if we chose kim that it is because we are fat slobs who sit on the couch and eat all day anything we want
I don’t find Kim’s dress flattering….rouching on already curvy hips? No no. Posh looks fab here, her legs seem to go for miles!
Kim looks great, but Posh is the winner. Always.
Kim!!!!!!!!!!!!! She is gorgeous! I hate Victoria… she is a skeleton, and a short hair make her look really masculin…. She looks so unhappy and mean all the time! With a husband (good looking) that rich, she could make an effort to smile and show us that she is happy to be that lucky! What a b%tch! Anyway, Kim is amazing… she is curvy and her butt is really big but she is hot! I am skinny but I love to have a body perfectly curvy like hers! and my husband will no see any problems about it either!
I hate the fakeness of Victoria, but I would have to go with her because she has a better body (minus the fake stuff)
How is her body better?
WOW! KIM! Not even a doubt about it! She’s just too perfect in this picture! Seriously…. WOW!
Posh. A million times over.
lol I’m not picking Kim because she’s a “real” woman.
I’m picking her because she has a better body and is overall much much sexier. Period.
My boyfriend is obsessed with her.
thank you to steph and all the others not calling kim a real women. i find it quite offensive.
I see more beauty in Kims body. Posh is just to skinny. IMO. She hasn’t always been as thin as she is now. I think th kims body is beautiful. I’d love to be in great shape like her.
Posh all the way – Ok, maybe without the fake boobs. Still, she had a gorgeous shape and I’d prefer thin over fat any day.
Kim’s not fat though.
Instant, you reply to EVERYONE! i dont think shes calling kim fat, i think it was a general statement. not everyone is attacking people here!
So what if I reply to EVERYONE? She picked Victoria, and than stated she prefers thin over fat, and since Kim is the one that Victoria is put against, IMO it’s implying that Kim is fat.
get a life and get off the stupid blogs. peace out, i have a real life to get back to! and ps, implying you are fat since your so defensive! awwww!
And I apologize to Elaine if I misread her post, and I apologize for coming off as attacking her. Again, if I had just included one little
my intention would have been a little clearer 
@Morgan’s: “get a life and get off the stupid blogs. peace out, i have a real life to get back to! and ps, implying you are fat since your so defensive! awwww!”
LOL In your own words, “Not everyone is attacking people here” I wasn’t attacking Elaine’s post, I was replying to it with my own observation. So why are you attacking me?
because your ignorant. point blank. im done with this conversation between us. I’m glad you’re LOLing though, people do that when they try to seem smug. It’s cute, very flattering, Bye now!
I’m sorry that I somehow got under your skin, Morgan. That wasn’t my intention. BTW, I was LOL’ing at the way you used my wording against me, and I was assuming you were including the oft over used implication that fat girls are defensive and see insults in every little thing as a joke.
*note to self, emoticons are a girl’s best friend, forgetting that gets me into trouble.
I think that if I had remembered to include a simple 
in my responses, it would have gone a long way to show that I wasn’t in any way intending to attack anyone.
You all need to calm down. When did this site become a battleground???
lol arent you replying almost just as much? if you had a life you wouldnt care what they say
Instant and Morgan, enough. But I do have to say Elaine does not seem as though she’s calling Kim fat. Just stating she’d prefer to be skinny and not fat.
I think they both look great in their own way. But I am partial to skinny ladies, so I’d have to say Vickie!
By calling her skinny, im not saying Kim is fat, im just saying Vickie is skinny
haha I was just messin with ya
oh so definitely Kim Kardashian! she looks amazing! posh doesn’t look bad.. her dress isn’t that great.. not my style but she carries it well.. her hair really suits her.. but Kim looks pretty perfect here in my opinion. just love her. (^_^)
soomewhere in between
whattook so long?:P both to extremes . yet both unique and very gorgous.
posh’s body looks kickin
kim ‘s body is sexy.
kim obviously wins but llets not forget that psoh works extra hard to lok god for photos,and succeds 89% of the time.
I have to admit ,judging from both photos it was hard to pick.
I forgot to mention how much I hate kim’s dress though.
I think both look good, but I pick Posh only because love, love, love her dress….I think both woman understand their body type well and go with it, even if one is curvy or one skinny they embrace who they are. Its nice
I like these two and for me this is a win, reason being vicky is the epitome of looking good at a skinny weight when u compare her to lindsay Victoria looks so much better and healthier can u beleive that! as for Kim she has one of the best curvy bodies around and the both have a great fashion sense.
I personally prefer curvy women, so I would say Kim. My only problem with Victoria is that it’s not her natural body. I have nothing against women who are naturally slim, in fact I think it looks good, but she has gone to an extreme.
She looked incredible back when she was in the Spice Girls, but she’s dieted and exercised herself away to almost nothingness, and I don’t find much sexy in that
That’s what I was saying. I don’t think she is “naturally” that thin.
I love Kim, and I hate Posh… but,
Posh definitely looks better. Look at her legs!
hmm that’s a hard one. if i could choose i would look like kim cause it’s prob a lot easier than being as thin as posh, haha
i say both of them look good. why is it every time they have a curvy girl they want to say, “that’s what a real woman.” at first i didn’t look at it as being offensive but then i realized it is because not all women have wide hips and big asses. skinny women are beautiful too and healthy. victoria looks good to me and yes she’s thin but so what? it fits her, as long she’s not starving herself to please hollywood then she’s alright to me. and anya needs to shut up with that “real woman” comment because you sound ignorant.
take one look at Victoria beckham and tell me honestly that she is naturally this thin.
This thinness is NOT attractive simply because it is unhealthy, and clearly in NO POSSIBLE WAY natural. The bombardment of images of very thing women in hollywood has led us on to believe that this is a natural body shape, when it is not.
you are the one who seems to be completely aloof to Victoria Beckham’s extreme and unhealthy eating (/lackthereof) regime, and plead ignorant to obvious unhealthiness that you claim is “natural” and also “real”.
puh lease. open your eyes and be honest with yourself. If you think unnatural and very very difficultly and unhealthily attained thinness is beautiful, then fine. But be honest about where it comes from; or don’t be ignorant to it as “another natural body type”.
and how do you know that victoria is unhealthy, huh? i’m not being ignorant but it seems you are being ignorant. all i’m saying is that people need to quick saying that this is what a real woman should look like, as if being slim is not real. that’s b.s. i don’t think women should be overly thin but i’m not going to sit here and say that having big breast and big asses is beautiful because women come in all shapes. yes she’s thin but don’t assume thay she’s unhealthy when you don’t even know her.
Steph,
I completely agree. Well said!
I have the exact same body type as victorias. I eat more than anyone I know and it all goes straight to my boobs. I am a size 00 yet have large boobs. Everyone thinks I don’t eat and have implants. (Obviously, I know Vic B. has implants but how do you know she doesn’t eat????) Don’t assume things about other people, especially just from a picture. I’m so glad there are people on here saying “Curvy does not define real women”. Women come in all shapes and sizes, and YES it is possible to be as skinny as Victoria B. and still be healthy.
As I say, my prediction was correct. Get it right every time! LOL
Kim wins.
HAHA Victoria no competition!
Kim totally….. Victoria is skinny.. Too skinny and just gross….
Victoria FOREVER!!!!!!!!!!!! She is a REAL superstar
Kim looks chubby and so ordinary!!
Come on there is NO contest. VB looks like a coat hanger where KK looks like the epitome of perfection with her tiny waist and curvy bust and hips. Anyone who says she looks chubby and ordinary has to be deluded or maybe even jealous.
Also anyone think Kim looks a bit like J-Lo in the face here?
most people associate “real women” with american women. and most of americans are obese.
Gotta say I love em both for very different reasons! I can’t choose sides here.Say what you will but I loves me some Poshy!! I am a very sharp dresser every day and I LOVE that she goes all out too. I am not as tacky as she will get but that is just Posh!! ….and Kim…she is just soooo beautiful!
Are you kidding? Curvy girls will always be way more attractive in all senses. Who really thinks that a skinny, almost anorexic type of woman is hot? They are horrible.
Curvy women are much more interesting to look at.
It dipends what you mean when you say “curvy”and “skinny”.We all understand this word in different ways.If for you Victoria is a skinny,almost anorexic type of woman,in my opinion you’re wrong.For me she isn’t anorexic at all,she looks perfect bodywise, and Kim isn’t curvy at all..she is just fat,not curvy.For me a curvy body is one of Monica Belluci for example.And I don’t agree with you that curvy women are much more interesting to look at if you are saying by this that Kim’s body is much interesting that Victoria’s body.For me it’s the opposite in this case and I think that there are also many other men who think like me.
The curvy breasty girl like Kim always get the nod in front of the cameras. A skinny type like Victoria generally fairs much better off camera. I have to agree. These are two extremes. Victoria being so skeletal and Kim so curvy, will definitely give the edge to Kim on camera. Kim may also have the prettier face. Kim has a very attractive complexion. I wouldn’t underestimate Victoria off camera though. Not shabby at all.
I love butts! Not Camels! Kims! Victoria doesn’t have any. I still love
them both! Extremes! Victoria has to be the ultimate small butt without
being unattractive and Kim the ultimate large butt without being
unattractive. I’ll settle with Queen Latifah because she probably can
cook!
Posh Posh Posh. she is so poised, put-together and elegant.
I love both these women, but Posh looks so fragile next to Kim.
I have the exact same body type as victorias. I eat more than anyone I know and it all goes straight to my boobs. I am a size 00 yet have large boobs. Everyone thinks I don’t eat and have implants. (Obviously, I know Vic B. has implants but how do you know she doesn’t eat????) Don’t assume things about other people, especially just from a picture. I’m so glad there are people on here saying “Curvy does not define real women”. Women come in all shapes and sizes, and YES it is possible to be as skinny as Victoria B. and still be healthy.
victoria is far sexier than kim.
kim isn’t as classy as victoria
Posh all d way,i like kim but i rather go for posh.kim looks good no doubt,bt posh is classy elegant,and outstanding….she gat courage and also hardworking,i prefer posh…she rocks
kim all the way. victoria is pretty, but she looked way better when she was in the spice girls. i can guarentee most guys would choose kim. shes not fat, she carries herself very well, her ass and boobs are fantastic and she has a little waist. she looks like princess jasmine! how wouldnt wanna look like her? victoria like i said is pretty but look at her neck, the thinness of her body makes her bones and tendents stick out more which in turn make her look older.
Funny how people keep describing Posh as classy; elegant e.t.c
Well surprise surprise curvier ladies can be just as classy and elegant if not more….Amma choose Kim cos i think Posh looks very unhealthy and sickly and if she would gain a little could really look much better cos she’s a pretty woman…The bones just kinda put you off…. Curvy Gurls All Da Waaaayyy!!!
none Kim is too curvy and Victoria too skinny.