Which Body Shape & Size Do You Prefer? Anna Kournikova VS Brooke Hogan!
April 2, 2009 in Anna Kournikova, Body Comparisons, Brooke Hogan, Skinny Versus Curvy by Versus
Battle of the extremes!
Notice how Anna’s legs are really half the size of Brooke’s legs… and even so, both girls are attractive in their own way - though I’d like to point out that Anna is naturally a much shapelier girl… she didn’t even look V-shaped when she had more lbs. on (I guess she lost part of her hips during the weight loss process). As for Brooke, she’s always been a big boned girl (the true meaning of the words, not what they use sometimes when they mean overweight).
Which Body Shape & Size Do You Prefer? Anna Kournikova VS Brooke Hogan!
Pick your favorite!
Anna! hands down!
Brooke
Neither!
Anna, thou art too skinny! And sorry, but the “big-boneded”-ness thing isn’t working out for Brooke, either.
Well she can’t help it, anyway she looks muscular and lean so what if she isn’t small.
anna! perfect body
neither realy. but if i had to choose it would be brook. the other girl is just way to skinny for me.
Anna, i like her body,brooke looks older than her age and i think anna is older but she looking young and beautiful
def brooke, i have always liked her body but usually hated what she put on it.
Neither. I think something in between would look better.
neither of them:|
Anna when she used to have some meat on her bones. But I like Brooke too. She’s natural.
Brooke!!!!!
i dont prefer both.
Without a doubt Brooke. Anna looks like a boy and is very unattractive. Brookes gorgeous.
What is it with you and calling thin women “boys”?
i think its because thin women lack typically natural feminine traits of curviness (hips, breasts, waist), hence making them looking boyish (as in, lacking these traits).
duh.
and by thin women i mean women as thin as anna. not all thin women. so that people don’t freak out at me.
It’s insulting, to say the least, and while she may lack the “feminine traits”, she in no way looks like a boy. She looks like an overly thin female.
instant, amen sista! im a thin girl and I lack hips and bigger breasts and ass. I am a damn size zero. I am still 118 at 5’7″, i only wear a 0 because of my hip size. But I in NO WAY look like a damn boy.
She does look like a boy. And when I say that I mean that when a woman starves herself or whatever she did too look like that and not being that skinny naturally then she looks like a boy because she’s want to look stick thin and be without any curves whatsoever.
I am not saying that a normal skinny girl looks like boys because you can’t change your shape, but when you choose too go for this look then you wants too look like a boy with not curves. Or else I can’t see what the purpose of it is.
And seriously she is not thin, she is downwright skinny and almost looks emaciated and worn out.
You’re still wrong, she in no way looks like a boy. I’m sorry, but if there are boys out there that look like starved women, then they might have something wrong with them too. Anna may not have “curves”, but she is still feminine in appearance, I don’t think I would mistake her for a boy, and to say she looks like a boy isn’t an opinion on her too-thin frame, it is an insult.
her thighs are as thin as a little boy so i agree with anya 100%. But i will say there are women who are thin but still have curves such as most victoria secret models. Anna has the body of an adolescent..not attractive
She doesn’t look like a boy because she has long flowing blonde hair and is dressed like a woman.
By a boy we don’t mean, A MAN
We mean a very young boy child.
So yes, her figure has the appearance of a pre-pubescent boy, not one of a man or a women.
I’m sorry if you find that insulting. It’s simply an aesthetic judgement that I’m pointing out.
For people to defend Anna’s figure so vehemently I find very strange… to me, she is clearly malnourished and underweight, period. Stop making excuses for it, and call it what it is for gods sakes.
Eh, I think she still has some boobs. Really skinny women, if they don’t have much definition to their waist DO look boyish if you look at their body but at least Anna still has a pretty feminine face.
perhaps, but i am solely commenting on her figure, not her face.
and if you ask me, it looks like she got a boob job.
Hmm tricky, i think Anna
This is a tough choice, because I think something in between would be much better than either of them. But I guess that’s the point… I’m leaning towards Brooke but somehow I think Anna looks better aestheically.
Anna, for sure.
If Brook would lose about 30 pounds she’d be like Anna, both have the same body type: wide shoulders and narrow hips aka athletic body
So the real question is: U like slim or chubby girls? I prefer Anna
What lose 30lb of muscle? Because she doesn’t have much fat to lose.
I think more to the point do you like skinny-fat girls or thick-lean girls….I prefer the latter personally.
Anna is soooo perfect. Brooke is dumpy…. looks like an overweight mall shopper ! But for the sensitive types here… she might be a very nice person,,, and I am sorry for choosing and expressing my opinion.
what’s a mall shopper? dont u shop at malls???
Yeah especially with that flat, lean stomach…………..idiot.
brooke!!! she is soo gorgeus….
i like Brooke Hogan
anna for sure…. brooke is fat.
Anna all the way. She has a perfect body. She is very beautiful.
anna…rexia? wow she’s quite skinny
brooke looks better only because she seems healthy
Why do some of y’all say that Brooke is fat/chubby? She’s not. Yea, she’s “big”, but that ain’t fat.
Totes Anna! Anyone who says Brooke is obvi overwieght..sorry but its true.
How could you say it’s true that she’s overweight?! That’s muscel (sp?) not fat! Not everyone’s body is made to be that small and Brook Hogan can’t help that. That is so not true! She looks great!
Good grief, how ignorant can people be?!?
Brooke ! wow super hot I love her body shape Anna looks like a boy
yEah brooke is like a big girl but she’s not fat she’s just big
and my vote goes for brooke cuz she’s curvier and she is nice i liker her 
Definitely Anna. Sorry but Brooke looks like a big hog.
umm– to the people saying that anna looks like a boy… get your eyes checked. ESPECIALLY when compared to brooke hogan, BROOKE is the one who looks masculine.
anna
duh!
I’d rather have your mom.
You know who you are.
brooke! oh and about all the “boy” comments. i’m a size zero and yes, sometimes i do look like a boy…
Wow. This is truly saddening to read. It actually make me sick, sure its fine if some of you like Anna’s body better and its fine again if you like Brookes more. Both girls are very attractive and both seem like lovely women.
Now this is a true fact. Brooke is not overweight, or fat. In the slightest. AT ALL. TRUE FACTS. You wanna see some fat? Google it and stop being so ridiculous. She’s got a healthy NORMAL body shape and I’m sure her BMI is in the healthy range. She’s well proportioned and seems like a lovely girl. She’s also well toned from what I can see.
It makes me so sad to read some of these comments and alot of you are what are wrong with todays society. Its quite sad really that some of you are saying the things you are. Some of you need to go and look up the word fat in the dictionary before you start calling Brooke.
And before I start getting accoused of being overweight or fat.. I am more like Anna’s body shape fyi. I just think its very sad people can’t enjoy these two women for what they are – gorgeous.
I think the owner of this site should look at what purpose it serves because to me it just seems to bring people down and gives stupid small minded people the oppourtunity to bash others and these celebrities which have never done anything to them.
Hear, hear. I agree completely with all that you’ve said. I begin to see more and more that this site only seems to attract those types of people that love to attack and insult one body type or the other. I always strive to make my observations either as positive as they can be, or neutral and non-inflammatory. I find it interesting to read others’ opinions too. Though it seems many go out of their way to get a rise out of others.
As for the ‘fat’ and ‘teenaged boy’ comments. I do not see anything overweight about Brooke. She has a larger bone structure and that is something that cannot be changed by losing weight. I also cannot see how Anna’s body looks like a pre-pubescent boy’s when she has breasts and hips (however slight) enough to change the shape of her thighs. No teenaged boy is going to have breasts, noticeable hips and shapely thighs. (Before anyone says it, I think it is pretty obvious I do not mean ‘Beyonce’ or ‘Kim Kardashian’ shapely thighs here, but you can see that there is a feminine curve to her thighs.)
I see what you mean about “bashing”, but we have to allow everybody to speak their mind, we can’t censor comments, even if they seem exaggerated. Also, I think that we get less insulting comments than other similar sites.
On a positive note, I think that it is clear that some people prefer Brooke and some prefer Anna… which basically means that all body types and sizes are beautiful, there is not just 1 standard of beauty – and this is the message this site is trying to send.
Okay folks, trust me Brooke ain’t fat or overweight. She is a thick muscular girl but still lean. Look at her flat, toned stomach. Fat people are flabby with rolls. I bet you anything they both have very similar levels of body fat. Anna is really what you’d call skinny-fat. She is thin but has little muscle, which is ironic considering she used to be very fit and lean before.
Skinny doesn’t equal lean and thick doesn’t equal fat.
Anna is not slim, she is just starving. I prefer Brooke cause she actually eats something.
brooke looks about 40!
Although I do admit Anna is a bit too thin, she still looks better than Brooke. Brooke is a very large girl, who makes herself look even bigger because of the skimpy clothes she wears.
I definitely think Brooke could benefit from loosing a few pounds, she’s a young girl and im sure it wouldnt be hard for her.
Why is no one offended that you’ve been asked scrutinize and rank these women’s bodies? This is absolutely disgusting. I can’t comment on these women’s habits because I don’t know them, so I can’t comment on their health, either. But I can say that reducing them to their bodies is dehumanizing.
EDM, this is a BODY gossip site, we talk about body types, shapes and sizes. This is our niche – I am sure that these celebs have great personalities, but we choose to debate on a subject of high interest for many women / girls. We might identify with these celebs, we might find them inspirational, we learn from their mistakes (unflattering looks), we learn what flatters each body type and so on… and I do not find that “dehumanizing” in any way.
People have certain preferences (some prefer skinny, some curvy), regardless if I ask them to share or not – and stating your preference is definitely not “disgusting”.
Brook Hogan is NOT a large girl at all. In fact, she is very well in shape. She just have larger bone structer. Of course she’s going to look bigger next to a very small woman but that doesn’t make her fat.
I must admit however I wouldn’t want neither one of their figures. but they both look great.
Brook Hogan is not fat. If you’ve seen her in smaller clothes, you can see that she’s actually well toned. Which tells me that she’s just big boned. And there is nothing wrong with that for those who feel she can stand to lose a few pounds. If she lose any more weight, she’ll look sick because her body isn’t meant to be skinny. I’ve seen different post of her on this website, and it shows her working out. Anyways, Anna is too small so I’m going to say I’d rather have Brook’s figure.
i actually kind of like them both
Whoever calls Brooke fat seriously has mental problems. How the fuck is she fat? Whoever calls her fat is a fucking idiot. Like one person said, if you wanna see fat, go look it up on google. She is very healthy and tonned looking. You can see she still has nice curves, if she was fat she’d have rolls. She doesnt. She’s tall with a bit of a bigger build. Get over it. Whoever says Anna has a nice body is seriously disturbed. She has stick thin legs. She may have had a nicer body before, but now she is way too skinny, not healthy looking at all. What is wrong with you people? All of you people saying Brooke is fat, just know guys like curves, and not stick thin stupid bitches like some of you seem to be. Please get your heads examined. And for everyone who says Brooke looks great….rock on !!
anna, hands down she doesnt look like a boy at all, i think there is way too much chubby and fat ppl here that hold grudges against petit or cute looking woman, who have no fat popping out of their bodies, because they want to accept themselves..
and its not because a woman has less curves that shes at all less feminine, so according to that obese woman would be more feminine because they have lots of curves? ridiculous… healthy for me is people who can move actually…
i particularly dont think brooke is actually kind of chubby… check out other photos of her
and by the way this website should be renamed “SLIM VERSUS CHUBBY”
Ummm…just because people defend thicker women doesn’t make them fat. I’m 125 pounds and I defend thicker women all the time. It’s not that we’re getting defensive, we just get sick and tired of certain people putting thicker women down. Skinny is a cute look, but it’s not cute when skinny women make fun and bash bigger women. IDK, you may be big. I don’t know what you look like, but I know fat, and Brook Hogan is not that. You wanna see some real fat? Google it. I’m sure you won’t find Beyonce’s, Rhianna’s or Brook’s picture. lol.
I’m a small boned girl but I sometimes wish I was big boned just so big boobs and a big butt would look good on me…lol…Brooke Hogan has the sexier bod here, she’s prettier too. Anna is more modelesque, more ‘high-fashion’ I guess, but I don’t think she she has any sex appeal compared to Brooke.
i’d normally go with the thinner person but anna looks alittle too stick thin
Anna, no matter what her shape would appeal as a beautiful woman. Her skin, even when she was playing tennis, has the look that makes you wish to be close to it. And she moves with a dancer-like grace.
Everything about the Hogan girl screams low-class trash. If she had Anna’s body, she’d look like a crack/meth wh**e. Bleached out unhealthy hair, walmart ill-fitting clothes, and moves like an offensive tackle…
ure totally right david! i hadnt noticed all that though
you are soo wrong , brooke doesnt look like trash at all, as you can tell she doesnt dress up unless she is going somewhere, brooke is just like me and you , she doesnt dress up every damn where she goes
she is pratically just a regular person just a daughter of a dad thats has money, DO YOU? i doubt it!
so maybe you should consider on thinking before you say(type)things.
They are both cute and both have the right bodies for their size! Brooke is never going to be a size 2 without looking anorexic. They both look healthy!
well. i would be brooke hogan’s size just the simple fact that i am her size
but anna is way too skinny look like she havent at in 1 week except salad. brooke is big bone ‘ not saying she fat’. big bone means ‘ the bones in your body are large and you cant help but to be a little think and if brooke get in skinner you would be able to see her bones ,because her bones are big ,
(here is an example): grab your wrist and put the skin and see how big your bones are
she in the middel
Anna looks really skinny here, but that`s ok, I love skinny bodies. So i`ll go with Anna. Brooke`s legs look short and thick in those jeans, especially next to Anna`s.
Anna by far!
I don’t like thick people. I don’t think anyone does, only guys who wanna smash ya. haha well that’s the truth. The only reason some girls wanna be thick is because they feel the need to prove to guys that they got a lot of meat, so the sex will be better to smash on. Lol I’m not dumb, I hear this everywhere.
Uhhhh, Aleska, I don’t know who the hell you hang around, but that’s the most ignorant type of s*** I’ve ever heard. Sex has nothing to do with why women want to be thick. Thick women with small waiste and full thighs and hips has been the ideal body shape for many centeries. Marilyn Monroe, Beyonce, ect are deseriable by men (and perhaps women) for many reasons other than sex.
Thick is attractive, skinny is attractive, hell, even big people can be attractive as long as they know how to dress their body shape. It’s the way you carry yourself ma. Confidence is also a very huge turn on for men. And whoever told you otherwise is dumb. It’s one thing to admire the thin body, but it’s another to put others down and to say that the only thing thick people are good for is sex. So you can get the hell out of here with that B.S. Let’s toss that theory out the window!
I don’t totally agree with Aleska but she does have a point. Personally i like slim girls so I prefer Anna’s look to Brooke’s but it’s true that some girls are too slightly built and too weak to cope with really full on sex. These girls can be great in bed but you need to be more careful with them and be ready to hold yourself back when it is getting too much for them. But sometimes you want a real “tear up” and for that you need a girl who is still gorgeous but is physically robust enough to cope with a strong guy with the leash off. Anna would never cope with that but Brooke would be fantastic.
Anna. Brooke’s body is somewhat disgusting to me. She’s so manly.
I prefer Anna’s body, but Brooke rocks the booty shorts. My body is similar to Anna’s and whenever I wear booty shorts, my legs look like sticks. I really don’t think those pants are flattering to Brooke’s shape, though. Drawing too much attention to a place that doesn’t need that much attention.
NEITHER!
we gotta give Brooke a break she does have Hulk’s body type BUT she doesnt dress right for her body type. it makes her look bigger then she actually is… Anna is perfect lean and toned! AND she knows how to dress her body..sexy yet classy.. Brooke seems to this the skimpier she dresses the thinner she will look although this picture proves otherwise.. If she dressed better she’d be a knockout!
Brooke is hot, Anna is boring.
ok brooke looks like a women anna looks like a boy but anna haves a better body
anna needs make up too look good iv seen her without make up i dont know y enrique iglesias is dating her she looks like a man so brooke
First off, you picked the most horrible picture of Brooke… She looks greasy here, her wardrobe never suited her in the first place. Anna looks like a tooth pick.. FU to everyone saying Brooke has an ugly body. She is in shape, just has a LARGE FRAME!!! SHE CAN’T HELP THAT. And for Anna, it’s the same thing! She’s probably naturally skinny. You can’t choose between the two.
Brooke=YUM
Anna looks like a broomstick……upside down…lol No,thanks.
Isn’t interesting how quickly overweight women are to judge thin/extremely slender women. Anna is an elite athlete…her thinness is most likely due to a lack of training–thus making her lose muscle mass. She has always been a petite person, but when you work out all day everyday, it’s only naturally to put on weight associated with muscle gain and such…it helps to protect your body/make you a better athlete. It’s so funny how people refer to her as boyish…lacking femininity, when in all actuality women come in all different shapes and sizes…so there really is not standard for judgment. What about stick thin women you get butt and breast implants…does that make them anymore feminine..it’s not natural…and neither is being slight overweight or overweight. How are “curves” to that extent more feminine than Anna’s figure? From an evolutionary perspective, it becomes more and more difficult, if not impossible to conceive children when a woman’s body is slightly-massively overweight.. If anything, Anna is secondly considered more feminine by several scientific studies pointing to a strong correlation between men’s ideal preference for women and feminine feaures including high cheek bones, symetrical features youthful looking faces, clear skin and perfect teeth. Studies have also found that men do prefer women according to the lastest pop cultural standard of beauty–thus in the united states, women who are thin like Anna are more desireable as they symbol status, wealth, class and education–considering that most educated people are thin and wealthy. It’s really quite interesting. Stop being so mean. I am a thin person myself, I’m 5 foot 6 1/2 and I weigh 108 pounds. I look and feel great and I get a lot of attention from men . I’m also an athlete…and again to prove my point…women who are healthy (athletes are healthy) able to provide for their families and communities (athletes are fit) from an evolutionary perspective are more desireable to the oppositive sex as it is a symbol of fertility and longevity whereas overweight women have stood to be an evolutionary symbol of poor health (as is acne, bad teeth, and so on)….I’m not trying to put anyone down because I think all women have qualities about them that are gorgeous…however, I don’t think its very nice to berate those who are thin as they are just as feminine if not more feminine that women with curves. I don’t condone obesity and really, in order to stop the obesity epidemic individuals need to get over the “big is beautiful and I’m proud” ideology because it’s extremely unhealthy and deadly. What’s so feminine about being so curvy or large that you have a difficult time conceiving because evolution doesn’t find you to be an adequate part of the human race to bring a child into this world…it’s all about making the world better, and in order to do that you have to start with yourself and take personal responsibility for your own eating habits, health and lifestyle.
(Ohh and a Side Note) I forgot to mention that..yes, women who are severely underweight experience amenorrhea……but that is only experienced at severe severe points of anorexia, bulimia (where individuals areover over weight) and severe medical conditions. With all of this said, Anna K is clearly not at the point of Amenorrhea…especially given that at my weight and height with a BMI that is technically underweight…I have never experienced this…and I may be thinner than Anna. I think she would have to lose about 15 more pounds to hit that point. Anyway, shes healthy…as are small asian women, small and extreemly tall east aricans and naturally thin lanky women. What about them isn’t feminine about them—especially when women shaped like this are perpetually represented in TOP SELLING male magazines and pornography. I know there is a makert for Big Beautiful Women—but the market for thin women is HUGE, and the market is shaped, controlled and essentially RULED by men. That’s what they want…so if the majority of American men thought that Anna looked terrible and “un-feminine” then it would not by any means be a multi-billion dollar business/industry. Love to all, Stop hating and appreciate your own body–don’t listen to others and stop criticizing people who aren’t like you, it only contributes to a hateful world…we are all women, lets get along. Women big and small are women and they are all feminine because they are WOMEN. So get along<4