Skinny VS Curvy Time! Nicky Hilton VS Alicia Keys!
September 14, 2009 in Alicia Keys, Nicky Hilton, Skinny Versus Curvy by Versus
Every event MUST have our trademark Skinny VS Curvy post and our picks for the VMAs are Nicky Hilton and Alicia Keys.
Alicia is a classic pear shape, with curvy hips, thick thighs and strong-looking legs, while Nicky is actually a very thin apple shape (she carried more weight in her middle area when she was heavier a few years back).
Skinny VS Curvy Time! Nicky Hilton VS Alicia Keys!
And since they have SUCH different legs, which pair do you like better?
Pick your favorite!
Note: Remember, this is just for expressing your preferences! This is not an actual battle and we DO believe both women and beautiful in their own way.
Neither this time. Alica Keys is way too chubby and Nicky Hilton is way too chicken-leggy.
You said it right! They both have legs that leaving something to be desired..
agree
Totally agree!
you’re right !
Figurewise I’d prefer something inbetween Nicky and Alicia. Nicky’s stick-thin legs freak me out a bit and Alicia’s are just a little too heavy for my taste.
As far as face is concerned I’d have to go with Alicia. She looks absolutely stunning here, whereas Nicky looks just haggard.
a tough one, the dress looks great on Nicky but her legs are a bit thin for my taste. Alicia has a nice curvy body but the ankle straps don’t flatter her legs + the hem is maybe too short. Aaaand since she’s a pear a v-neck might be nice to show off her slimmer upper body. It’s a tie for me, both look ok but something’s missing. (An ok is more than i usually would give Nicky so in that way she’s the winner
)
I like Nicky’s body type better, but she is definitely too thin. If she gained 10 lbs, she’d be hot!
I’m not really a fan of the chunky leg/pear shaped look.
What do you mean the “chunky leg/pear shaped look”? Women are BORN with that shape, they don’t choose it like they choose a dress.
Nicky looks like a 12-year-old boy dressing in drag for a few laughs at the Middle School talent show. Nicky can CHOOSE to eat something and maybe look like a real woman.
Alicia is a lot prettier but I would MUCH prefer Nikky’s body. I think her legs are fine apart from the razor sharp knees. Alicia’s just look chubby.
…yes we DO
however, i don’t like neither of this girls
i mean bodywise…
and their outfits as well…
I have the same kind of legs as Alicia Keys, and I would NEVER and I really mean NEVER wear a dress that short!! I always try to hide my knees since it’s not my best feature.
I choose neither. Nicky´s are too bony and Alicia´s are pretty chubby and shapeless. The interesting thing is that their waists look about the same size, despite the big weight difference.
yuuuck
ugly face on the left and a strange and not so nice body on the right. Nicky Hilton is REALLY ugly 
Nicky without a doubt..
i think both women look beautiful. not the best outfits but still look good.
Why do I get the whole “don’t fight” thing is for a comment I posted a few days back? hehe..good times. Anyways..
Ah, Not a huge fan of etheir legs, but they’re both nice looking.
Alicia is too thick for me, but Nicky’s are too stick like.
not a huge fan of either figure but they both look nice.
Alicia’s face is way pretty
I have to go with Alicia here, Nikky too thin, I’m a leg man, Alicia’s are better shaped. She would look better in jeans, better in a bathing suit. Boney legs are ugly, makes the person look ill.
yay! leg men that arent all about the skinnies!!! i hate when ppl are leg men but only like skinny stick supermodel types! to me…thats not sexy (long yes…but not skinny twigs!l long is cool tho.) unless its skinny yet nicely shaped…pamela anderson! i love her legs…so jealous…
Neither, Nikki’s legs don’t have much shape and Alicia’s have a little too much meat on them. Perhaps something in between?
Nicky Hilton!!
GO ALICIA…..
I would rather look thick and healthy then like I been on the Hollywood COKE!!!!
YES, her ankles are just a little to thick but she is big bone she cant help it duhhhh people STOP think about it
GET WIT IT SKINNY IS NOT IN…. HEALTHY IS!! WHETHER ITS IN A SMALL FRAME OR LARGER FRAME
I wonder why Nicky hasnt got a nose job already.
Alicia’s gorgeus… but thee leegs, maybe little lap running for you
It’s weird, but everytime I see a pic of a skinny girl alone, I can envy her for her body. But when I see the same skinny girl next to a girl with a softer, more feminine body, like Alicia Keys, the skinny girl doesn’t seem that pretty any longer…
I was thinking the same …
Nicky has great legs,long and thin.I personally think Alicia ‘s body is very unattractive
Alicia looks better overall -outfit and tan-wise. Her legs do need to be toned a bit more.
Alicia Keys is gorgeous…and there is absolutely NOTHING wrong with her legs….she’s curvy, thick and pretty. Too many Barbie doll lovers here. She’s classic old-school voluptuous….these guys today would have called Marilyn Monroe fat. Alicia is exactly why Christina Hendricks is gorgeous too…curvy, thick, healthy, and sexy.
Alicia all the way, she has lovely shapely legs, Nicky is just too skinny
Alicia has tree trunk legs. They have NO shape.
some of ya’ll kill saying that Alicia Keys is too chubby? are you serious, Hands down she’s better in the face and body wise, Nicky Hilton ain’t got nothing on her. Besides with looks, at least Alicia has the talent, What is Nicky is famous for?
Alicia is the clear winner for me- totally healthy and feminine. Pretty and sexy too in my opinion. Nicky Hilton looks a little like a drag-artist to me with the harsh look and bony knees, not my type. If she put some weight on, I’m sure she’d lose that look. Also, a pair of thighs that don’t look as if they’re able to meet in the middle without the knees getting there first doesn’t seem appealing!
Alicias the bomb like those body types .
If you typically like white girl u may not like a girls with a big booty and thick legs
I love alicia keys thick legs yummm
would the women stop commenting – well all know u wanna be anorexic – that gross .
Where the heck did Alicia’s beefy legs come from? I always imagined her a lot smaller. Maybe its just a bad angle? Nicky is too thin for my liking. She’s pretty tall right? Her hair looks really pretty tho! Ugh, but I can’t stop staring at Alicia’s heels… those things are going to snap!!!
alicia is cross eyed don’t see the appeal, talented though, nicky too skinny.
Its obvious the race of those who think the Hilton chick looks good and Alicia doesnt. Not going to disguise my race by saying the obvious. Alicia is BANGIN. She has the perfect body AND legs. So glad she doesnt look like she hasnt eaten in a year like the chick next too her. No coincidence that the world has taken notice and trying to get lip and butt implants and tanning themselves to an early grave. Give me Alicia, Beyonce and Kim Kardashian ANY day.
Alicia all the way! There are lots of beautiful girls with lovely, super slim legs, slighter and more slender than Nicky’s, but Nicky’s legs look so scrawny! Alicia’s legs look strong and sturdy and so much sexier than Nicky’s!
YES
alicia is beautiful 
i like her legs she has a nice strong figure – she looks like a woman rather than a man like other skinny Celebs.
EEEEEWWWW to both!! I’m sorry but were there no other choices than elephant legs Alicia and bracket legged Nicky? Seriously!
HAH! YOU PEOPLE NEED TO READ THE QUESTION AGAIN… it says if you would prefer Nicki to Alicia… IF THOSE WERE YOUR ONNLY TWO OPTIONS IN LIFE, which would you prefer….
if i was a man, i would prefer a strong beautiful healthy looking woman – like ALICIA KEYS. [[BBBEEEAUTIFFFUL]]
Nikki and other skinny celebs think its sexxxyyy, but, i would rather have something to grab on to. XD
ALICIA HANDS DOWN! IF IT AINT THICK, IT AINT RIGHT!
Nick is so SEXEY……. @ for Alicla is was to fat!!!!!!!!!
It’s so easy to judge… Bet you’re all twice as fat and just sit around, eating and pouring sause in your laptop while criticizing beautiful, perfectly fine looking women. This is the most stupid blog ever -.-
Nikki looks unhealthy…she probably calorie counts to an extreme. I think even if Alicia lost a whole bunch of weight, her legs would retain that thicker shape, it’s probably genetic. That being said, a woman can only work with what God gave her, and I definitely think she’s working it! What’s the point of condemning a woman for the body she’s born with? So cruel. Do you want her to get plastic surgery so you can then judge her for that? This is a beautiful girl. Period. It’s one thing to judge her hair or clothes, but quite another to judge the body underneath it all.
The Hilton girl doesn’t look awful…she just looks hungry. What kind of life is to to be so worried about eating too much? If she looks “better” to you, you might want to get your head checked because all I see is poor health. If the girl ate according to her body’s needs, I imagine her shape would definitely be a bit fuller.
[...] NOT-WEIGhT-(ShAPE!!)Alicia Keys-Pear- shapeNicky Hilton-Apple- shapehttp://skinnyvscurvy.com/alicia-keys/ski [...]